York vs
Shutterfly Review
We're crazy about printed photos!
We ordered the same 10 photos from York and Shutterfly, scanned them all in, and created this guide just for you.
York (Test: Glossy)
Shutterfly (Test: Glossy)
York (Test: Glossy)
Shutterfly (Test: Glossy)
Or see the full review
Pricing, shipping, paper quality, and other juicy details
When we tested | August 2020 | August 2020 |
Summary | York creates a nice-quality print. However, we noticed some cutting issues in our test order. 4/10 of our photos had white edges left from the cutting process, in particular the square print. | While Shutterfly's prints are cheaper than many others, be careful to check their shipping costs. In our tests, other print labs like Walgreens offered much cheaper shipping, whereas Shutterfly charged $4.30 to ship 10 photos. In addition, Shutterfly scored among the lowest in quality for classic photo prints. |
Print quality (local pickup) | Online only | Online only |
Print quality (online orders) |
10 Photos: $2.64 $0.09 4x6s + $1.74 to ship 3-10 days |
10 Photos: $6.10 $0.18 4x6s + $4.30 to ship 5-7 days |
Local pickup available | No | No |
Cost per 4x6 print (local pickup) | Online only | Online only |
Formats available for pickup | Online only | Online only |
Finishes available for pickup | Online only | Online only |
Paper type for pickup orders | Online only | Online only |
Pickup speed | Online only | Online only |
Online only | Online only | |
Online ordering available | Yes | Yes |
Cost per 4x6 print (online) | $0.09 | $0.18 |
Formats available online | 4x6, 4x5.33, 4x4, Wallet(4), 5x5, 5x7, 8x10 | 4x6, 4x4, 5x7, Wallet(4), 8x8, 8x10, up to 20x30 |
Finishes available online | Glossy,matte | Glossy,Matte,Pearl,Cardstock |
Paper type for online orders |
Fujicolor Crystal Archive 22 millimeters thick |
Fujicolor Crystal Archive 22 millimeters thick |
Cheapest shipping option |
$1.74 To ship 10 photos
|
$4.30 To ship 10 photos
|
Delivery speed for cheapest shipping option | 3-10 days | 5-7 days |
Order online | Order online |
York vs
Shutterfly
print quality comparison
On 2/13/20, we ordered the following photos from York. On 2/13/20, we ordered the same photos from Shutterfly.
We scanned in both sets of prints without color correction.
Here's how York compares to Shutterfly.
York (Test: Glossy)
Shutterfly (Test: Glossy)
York (Test: Glossy)
Shutterfly (Test: Glossy)
York (Test: Glossy)
Shutterfly (Test: Glossy)
York (Test: Glossy)
Shutterfly (Test: Glossy)
York (Test: Glossy)
Shutterfly (Test: Glossy)
York (Test: Glossy)
Shutterfly (Test: Glossy)
York (Test: Glossy)
Shutterfly (Test: Glossy)
York (Test: Glossy)
Shutterfly (Test: Glossy)
York (Test: Glossy)
Shutterfly (Test: Glossy)
York (Test: Glossy)
Shutterfly (Test: Glossy)
York envelopes
When you order photos from York, here's what you can
expect the envelope to look like.
Compare York and local labs
Compare York and online labs
4x6 photo tips
How to Send 4×6 Photos In the MailHow Big is a 4x6 Photo?
Photo credits
Atlantic puffin photo by @miss_oharaCardinal photo by @drphotomoto
Turn your phone into a disposable camera.
See your photos for the first time when
they show up in the mail in 7-9 days.
Talk to the hand